
The polished announcement came as they always do these days, via social media flourish and practiced prose. Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love declared for the NFL draft this week, punctuating a brilliant collegiate career with numbers that etched his name alongside legends in South Bend lore. He rushed for more yards in a single season than any Fighting Irish back since Allen Pinkett in the 1980s. He broke Jerome Bettis' single season touchdown record. He finished third in Heisman voting, no small feat for a running back in this quarterback obsessed era. And like clockwork, the college football machine produced another early departure, another unfinished story, another young man swapping golden helmets for golden opportunities.
Love's decision follows a familiar script. Star athlete rises to prominence through breathtaking performances. University markets his heroics to sell tickets and merchandise. Coaching staff extracts every ounce of production while publicly praising the player's character. Then just as academic transcripts are supposed to matter most, the athlete leaves campus chasing professional riches. We nod along approvingly, framing this as the natural order when really it's the inevitable result of a fundamentally disordered system.
Consider the cognitive dissonance surrounding Love's departure. Notre Dame touts itself as an institution where athletes truly experience the student half of student athlete. The university's famed Golden Dome gleams with academic prestige, its football program boasting one of the highest graduation rates among power conference schools. Yet Love departs with eligibility remaining, bypassing senior year classrooms for senior level contracts. This isn't an indictment of Love, but rather the economic gravity pulling him toward an NFL checkbook that college athletics cannot match, despite generating billions off young labor.
Rewind to the moments that made Love a household name. The 89 yard touchdown sprint against Ohio State where he turned a routine counter play into an ESPN Top 10 highlight. The four score outburst against rival USC where the Coliseum crowd fell silent beneath his cleats. The Sports Illustrated cover proclaiming him the next great Notre Dame back after a 200 yard demolition of Clemson. These feats enriched the university's brand immeasurably while Love earned precisely zero dollars from jersey sales bearing his number.
Now the NFL offers restitution, a marketplace finally valuing his talents at something approximating fair value. We shouldn't feign surprise when players like Love sprint toward that payday, not when the alternative involves risking career ending injury for another season of campus pageantry. Remember Jaylon Smith, another Notre Dame defensive phenom who suffered catastrophic knee damage in his final college game. His draft stock plummeted from top five pick to second round afterthought, costing him nearly 20 million dollars in guaranteed money before he ever took a professional snap.
These calculations are unavoidable for elite talents weighing stay or go decisions. College football wants athletes to embrace the fiction of amateurism even as their coaches collect seven figure salaries funded by TV deals built on player performances. The NCAA spent decades selling the lie that scholarships constituted fair compensation while suing athletes to prevent them from profiting off their own names. Though recent NIL reforms have loosened restrictions, they've also intensified pressure on top players to maximize earning windows that slam shut faster than a blitzing linebacker.
Love enters a stacked 2026 running back class where draft position dictates financial destiny. First round picks receive fully guaranteed contracts averaging over 10 million dollars. Slip to the third round, and guarantees shrink to barely 1 million. For someone who grew up in a St. Louis household where financial instability was a constant opponent, these numbers aren't abstract concepts. They represent generational wealth, insurance against the violence his body absorbs every carry. When college fans admonish players for leaving early, they ignore that staying risks sabotaging the very futures universities claim to prioritize.
This tension manifests in how we discuss draft prospects. Coaches and scouts curiously fixate on workload when evaluating running backs. Too many carries, they argue, indicates diminished pro potential. Yet those same voices never question why elite runners face such heavy college workloads. The hypocrisy stings. Colleges run star backs into the ground because winning now trumps longevity concerns, then NFL franchises downgrade prospects for the wear and tear accrued serving college programs. These young men become damaged goods before ever negotiating their first contract.
Love carried the ball 199 times this season, 43 more attempts than his previous two seasons combined. Notre Dame leaned on him as their offensive identity shifted following midseason quarterback injuries. His production soared. His highlight reel expanded. And his professional risk tolerance was stretched thinner with each collision. The same coaches who prepped him for NFL interviews now encourage 25 touch games because trophies demand sacrifice. It’s a brutal calculus where athletes pay compounding interest on their physical capital while programs collect immediate dividends.
Historical context sharpens the picture. Since 2010, only one Notre Dame player drafted in the first three rounds has returned for his senior season offensive lineman Ronnie Stanley in 2025. Stanley went sixth overall after that final year, proving patience can pay. But for every Stanley success story, there are 10 cautionary tales of players like linebacker Jaylon Smith or defensive back Julian Love who watched draft stock tumble after choosing collegiate glory over professional pragmatism. This track record doesn’t escape current players during draft deliberations.
Fans often misdirect frustration at athletes rather than systems. When Love announced his departure, online forums crackled with accusations of disloyalty. Some called him greedy. Others predicted NFL failure like this wasn’t the same back who torched SEC defenses for 200 yard games. What these critics miss is that the NFL draft constitutes the only leverage college athletes truly wield. The NCAA transfer portal allows movement between schools, but only switching uniforms for similar compensation structures. The draft offers genuine pay commensurate with production. Is it any wonder players bolted for this long awaited payday?
Modern athletes also contend with shifting public sentiment about college sports itself. Four decades ago, leaving school early felt transgressive, a rejection of education’s inherent value. Reggie Bush famously drew criticism for departing USC after three seasons, though few batted eyes when coach Pete Carroll later bolted for the NFL. Today’s fans witnessed billion dollar TV deals and coaching carousels proving college football operates as a high stakes business. Players recognizing their role as revenue generators rather than just campus idols isn’t greed. It’s clarity.
Love walks this tightrope better than most. His announcement included heartfelt gratitude toward Notre Dame, a nod to universal truths beneath this modern drama. He thanked coaches, academic advisors, teammates, family and training staff. He spoke of the university community forging him not just as a player but a man. These pleasantries aren’t obligatory. They reveal genuine appreciation for experiences money can’t buy. But appreciation doesn’t pay bills or secure families. Love’s polished messaging reflects maturity, not manipulation. He understands optics influence public perception and thus endorsement potential. That savvy alone makes him NFL ready.
His draft journey will fascinate. Notre Dame runners occupy treacherous NFL territory. Recent Irish alums Josh Adams and Tony Jones Jr became undrafted free agents, while Dexter Williams lasted barely two seasons. Contrast that with the immortal Jerome Bettis, whose Hall of Fame career defied collegiate position switches and unimpressive combine numbers. Pro success remains mercurial regardless of draft slot. Love possesses the all purpose skills modern offenses covet. His hands out of the backfield drew comparisons to Christian McCaffrey during November games. Yet NFL front offices increasingly devalue running backs, wary of short career spans at football’s most punishing position.
Perhaps this reality check explains why Love's announcement landed with lighter celebration than his on field exploits merited. Yes, social media filled with congratulatory posts from teammates and fans. But the broader college football ecosystem barely paused before shifting focus to recruiting replacements and next season’s prospects. This cold transition illustrates the industrial nature of big time college sports. Players aren’t people but interchangeable parts keeping assembly lines humming. When one piece wears out or moves on, numerous others await insertion.
There’s poetic tragedy here. Love spent three years building his Notre Dame legacy, breaking records older than some teammates, pouring sweat and blood into golden helmets. Yet within months, freshmen will claim his locker, coaches will install new schemes, and the stadium crowd will roar just as loud for his successor. Football programs survive individual departures, no matter how spectacular. This institutional resilience comforts fans but exposes how quickly even transformative players become nostalgia.
We don’t know how Love's story ends. Maybe he becomes the next Josh Jacobs, an overlooked back shocking pundits by winning Offensive Rookie of the Year. Or maybe he fades into preseason roster cuts, another cautionary tale for underclassmen considering early jumps. Regardless, his choice highlights college football's unsustainable economic model, where labor provides immense value but receives disproportionately little security. Until this imbalance resolves, players like Love will keep choosing NFL paychecks over collegiate pomp. And they’ll be right to do so every time.
His final touchdown as a Fighting Irish player came against Stanford, a seven yard burst where he spun past two defenders before diving across the goal line. The crowd thundered appreciation for what they instinctively knew might be his last South Bend score. In that moment, athlete and institution existed in perfect harmony. It’s the memory Notre Dame will market for decades. It’s the highlight reel moment Love parlayed into professional opportunity. Both truths coexist, revealing college football’s beautiful contradiction. We celebrate the athlete while exploiting his ambitions. We cherish his loyalty while understanding why he must leave. And we'll miss him terribly while already scanning the horizon for who comes next.
By William Brooks