Article image

An indie studio's wild ride through broken promises and last minute rescues proves creativity doesn't need permission slips

Let me tell you about the time I almost funded an indie game by maxing out three credit cards. This was back in 2017, when every pitch meeting ended with some executive muttering about 'genre viability' while avoiding eye contact. Spoiler alert, we didn't ship. But I still remember that taste of creative desperation metallic fear at 3 AM wondering if chasing this dream would torpedo my credit score. That's why Dispatch's David versus Goliath story hits so hard.

Picture this, a scrappy team of Telltale Games veterans brewing up something wild, a superhero workplace comedy where saving the world involves as much paperwork as punching aliens. They nailed the chemistry. Found killer voice talent. Built mechanics tighter than Robert Downey Jr's Iron Man suit. And what did publishers say when AdHoc Studio knocked? 'Interactive storytelling is dead.' 'Who buys comedy games?' 'Maybe try something more like Fortnite?' All delivered with that special condescension reserved for artists believing too hard in their vision.

Here's the kicker though. Those same publishers now falling over themselves to sign AdHoc's next project? Identical to those who ghosted them for seven years. The industry's hypocrisy gleams brighter than Malevola's spandex. We claim to champion innovation while demanding guarantees like Vegas bookies. Remember when Stardew Valley's creator got rejected for being 'too niche'? How Hollow Knight developers maxed personal savings to finish? Yet every time these underdogs succeed, you'll find executives suddenly saying they 'saw the potential all along.'

Meanwhile in Dispatch's development trenches, chaos reigned. Their publisher collapsed mid production thanks to the Embracer Group implosion, that financial death star sucking up studios just to spit them out bankrupt. AdHoc avoided becoming cosmic dust by stitching together contract gigs, basically working two full time jobs. Day job for Wolf Among Us 2 night shift polishing code fueled by cold pizza. The grind demanded soul crushing sacrifices, like abandoning a beloved characters when voices changed along with distribution rights.

You never know which compromises will haunt you. Years back I killed a pet character, a chain smoking robot squirrel named Rusty much weirder than Dispatch's scrapped Saja Boy homage. I still mourn rusty daily. But surviving means flexibility. Dispatch's team stayed nimble, pivoting from live action concepts to full gaming glory when COVID scuppered their Netflix style plan. And here's where their rebellion matters most, they wouldn't settle for just surviving.

Without publishers breathing down their necks, AdHoc embraced creative insanity. Drew joke comics about office drama between superhero coworkers. Designed mission reports doubling as passive aggressive HR memos. Leaned into bizarre hidden lore that players might never find. That freedom birthed Dispatch's soul. Compare that to cookie cutter sequels dumped quarterly by risk averse conglomerates, soulless treadmills where creativity equals whatever sold yesterday.

Let's address the cynical view though. Critical Role's involvement surely greased some wheels. Yes, having Dungeons Dragons royalty cosign helps. But let's not pretend celebrity endorsements guarantee success. Remember Keanu Reeves promoting Cyberpunk 2077? Exactly. Whatever marketing juice Critical Role provided, AdHoc delivered on the product. Their weird little office comedy now rivaling AAA blockbusters.

So what comes next for studios watching AdHoc's self publishing rebellion? Expect copycat business plans, obviously. Also policy fights brewing in the European Union seeking better indie protections post Embracer wreckage. Venture capital vultures circling successful teams with exploitative offers. And thousands of developers scribbling pitches between underpaid shifts at Gamestop.

Personally, I hope indie devs study Dispatch's seven year hustle. How they weaponized rejection into creative fuel. Monetized passion while keeping integrity intact. The publisher exodus became their superpower, freeing them from focus group mandates and sales targets. And if bigger studios don't learn from this, expect more empty husks chasing algorithms while true innovation happens elsewhere.

Some advice for surviving publisher purgatory though. First, protect core team culture like life support. AdHoc kept writing sessions absurdist through delayed paychecks. Second, diversify income like survivalists stockpile beans. Contract gigs became safety nets. Third, stay defiantly weird. Nobody needed another generic military shooter.

Now pardon me while I check my credit score. Because someday, maybe I'll ignore industry naysayers again. After all, Rusty deserves resurrection.

Disclaimer: The views in this article are based on the author’s opinions and analysis of public information available at the time of writing. No factual claims are made. This content is not sponsored and should not be interpreted as endorsement or expert recommendation.

Thomas ReynoldsBy Thomas Reynolds