
There's a particular cruelty to fame that surfaces in death. The brighter the spotlight during life, the more chaotic the shadows become when the curtain falls. This uncomfortable truth now haunts the legacy of Hong Kong acting legend Benz Hui and Singapore television personality Collin Chee, two men whose friendship is now forever tinged by a privacy controversy no one could have predicted.
The entertainment world recently mourned Hui, beloved by fans worldwide as Foon Hei Gor after his career defining role in the Line Walker crime series. When the 76 year old veteran succumbed to cancer related complications in late October, the industry prepared for a dignified farewell. His family organized quiet, invitation only services in mid November requesting no photography, no recordings, no social media tributes from attendees. A simple wish for these complicated times, perhaps too simple for those conditioned to sharing every moment for public consumption.
Enter Collin Chee, the affable Singaporean host and actor with longstanding ties to Hui's family. Having worked alongside Hui's wife Angeli Lung during their Television Corporation of Singapore days and even co hosted their daughter Charmaine's wedding just last year, Chee clearly arrived at the Hong Kong funeral as more than casual acquaintance. Yet in speaking extensively with Singaporean media about the proceedings he inadvertently ignited a firestorm. Discussions of the ceremony's customs, descriptions of stepson eulogies, even revelations about TVB's commemorative video montage crossed lines the family had desperately tried to establish.
Charmaine Hui's subsequent Instagram missive cut deep. Without naming names, she thanked respectful attendees while singling out one Singaporean guest for leaking details. Her phrase still burns, immense disappointment in this individual. Grief translated into quiet fury. The digital community swiftly connected dots pointing to Chee, while Hong Kong tabloids stoked flames with inflammatory headlines. When pressed by Singapore's Shin Min Daily News, the slightly bewildered Chee offered contrition, insisting his aim was honoring Hui's legacy, not invading privacy. But apologies over international calls fell into silence, highlighting how grace sometimes looks different depending on which side of tragedy you stand.
The cultural complications here loom large. Hong Kong funerals operate under different social contracts than many Western services, designed for intimate closure rather than public performance, particularly for Buddhist families honoring traditional mourning practices. Meanwhile industry veterans like Chee genuinely believe discussing a colleague's farewell showcases admiration. One insider explained how decades in the regional entertainment business ingrain a reflex with glossy magazines and talk shows require producing sound bites and anecdotes, especially about veterans. The tragic irony? In trying to salute Hui's career, Chee violated the very discretion the Hui family chose to prioritize their healing.
But this goes beyond cultural clashing oversights. Funeral leaks now join paparazzi chases and gossip blogs in entertainment's problematic relationship with grief. One recalls Tom Cruise crashing a very private memorial service for Scientology leader David Miscavige's son, broadcasting solemn moments to worldwide tabloids. Or the grotesque scenes outside Aretha Franklin's funeral where reporters jockeyed for shots of celebrities entering the church. The disgusting competition to monetize mourning keeps intensifying, making families increasingly guarded even around so called friends at their most vulnerable.
Every celebrity widow or parent who shuts down a Twitter account after losing a loved one understands this paradox. Intimacy becomes impossible when every acquaintance becomes potential source. Rumors swirl that certain Hong Kong entertainment circles praise Charmaine Hui's restrained but devastating public statement over Chee's weepy media apology, seeing her approach as preserving dignity while signaling clear boundaries. Others quietly confirm how often media gather intelligence from peripheral players rather than family members themselves, targeting those perceived as eager for momentary relevance by association.
Lost somewhat in this discourse about media ethics and mourning decorum remains the actual human subject. Benz Hui commanded legitimate adoration across generations. His portrayal of triad leader Foon Hei Gor transcended crime drama tropes, becoming a cultural touchstone in Hong Kong television. Industry tributes keep emphasizing how he mentored younger actors while maintaining almost unheard of industry longevity. One former Line Walker co star shared privately how Hui arrived hours early for funeral scenes, quietly practicing holding his hands just right to honor real life triad funeral customs. That obsessive commitment underlies why friends felt compelled to honor him publicly while the family recoiled at those same outward displays.
Perhaps most heartbreaking is how this discord overshadows meaningful charity work stemming from Hui's passing. Multiple outlets confirm the family redirected all condolence money to cancer research, a silent gesture showing where their focus lies. Meanwhile Chee's blundered goodwill mission has seen Brunei event organizers pause future collaborations pending this controversy fading. Everyone loses except headline writers chasing clicks.
What comes next involves painful introspection for entertainment cultures globally. When digital immortality means every life event exists for public dissection, how do professionals navigate basic human courtesies around death? Rising Korean American actress Maia Reficco ignited debate last year after demanding journalists delete photos taken during her grandfather's funeral procession. Her blunt Instagram plea resonated, calling out the soul crushing disrespect of treating grief as content. Many young artists have started including privacy clauses in contracts regarding life events. Yet these awkward formalities don't account for impulsive interviews conducted with shaking voices outside funeral halls.
We might speculate whether Hui himself would've chuckled wearily about Chapter drama spilling beyond Line Walker scriptlines. Those familiar suggest the pragmatic star held complicated feelings about fame. He frequently visited Singapore on work assignments without local publicity, choosing quiet fish head curry meals with friends over red carpets. Some interpret Chee's emotional interviews as mirroring Hui's original kindness when the Singaporean entered Hong Kong's entertainment world. If true, it presents agonizing poetic symmetry one actor extending praise, another family experiencing pain.
Ultimately Hermes Birkin bags stuffed with tissues won't resolve modern media morality debates. But anyone who watched Charmaine Hui grow up in entertainment's glare, now married and grappling with unimaginable loss, must consider whose narrative matters more. Chee may claim good intentions over broken privacy, but few walk away from parental death wanting colleagues philosophizing over their coffin decor or cousins’ eulogies. Perhaps when other industry figures see Charmaine's Instagram dots lingering over apologies unanswered, they'll understand her silence screams louder than leaked funeral details ever could.
Funerals represent sacred commas between living memories and eternal legacies. The Hui family sought a period, full stop finality with dignity intact. A grieving daughter drafted rules born from exhaustion, not malice. Chee's parched voice messages and unanswered texts now float through telecommunications satellites, digital echoes of trust fractured. Entertainment loves turning death into content, exploiting last moments for content. But real life deserves quiet revolt against that voracious machine, finding peace behind unrecorded moments where genuine love requires no audience.
By Vanessa Lim