
Picture this. You are at a family reunion, and Uncle Bob starts dredging up that awkward incident from 2020 when everyone panicked bought toilet paper. Instead of a quick chat over tea, it escalates into hiring squads of lawyers, digging through old diaries, and racking up a bill that could fund a small island nation's infrastructure. Welcome to the UK's Covid inquiry, where the postmortem of the pandemic has morphed into a fiscal feast for legal firms, with taxpayers left holding the check for well over £300 million combined.
The story unfolds like a bad sequel to a disaster movie. The inquiry kicked off in 2022, tasked with dissecting everything from early warnings to lockdown calls across ten sprawling modules. Two are done, eight to go, and the finish line glimmers somewhere around 2027. Sounds thorough, right? Sure, if thorough means expensive. The core inquiry has burned through £192 million already, with projections pushing past £200 million. But here is the kicker. Government departments have matched that with their own £101 million splurge from mid 2023 to mid 2025, mainly on lawyers and a small army of 248 staffers across outfits like the Cabinet Office, Home Office, and health agencies. Legal fees alone gobble more than half that pot. And this excludes the time officials spend prepping testimonies or sweating in the witness box.
Why the mega spend? Call it defensive driving on a road to accountability. Inquiry insiders whisper of a government posture that feels more like a fortress than a open book. Documents arrive late, key bits get redacted or blocked, sparking courtroom drama. Remember the tussle over ex Prime Minister Boris Johnson's digital chit chat, personal logs, and scribbles? It landed in High Court, where the government took a judicial knee. They framed it as a principled stand on relevance, but critics see shadows of hostility. The Cabinet Office insists full cooperation, eyes on future readiness. Fair enough, pandemics do not send RSVPs. Yet, when your response costs rival the inquiry itself, eyebrows arch higher than a giraffe at a basketball game.
Let us zoom out for context, because this is not the first time Britain has thrown cash at truth seeking. Public inquiries are a national pastime, born from tragedies demanding answers. Think Bloody Sunday in 1972, where soldiers fired on Derry protesters, leading to a probe costing millions in today's money but wrapping faster. Or the Iraq war dossier debacle, another multi year marathon with eye watering tabs. The Covid one dwarfs them, thanks to its epic scope touching every citizen's life. Unlike narrower probes, this beast probes readiness, decisions, procurement fiascos, and care home woes. No wonder it is pricey. Still, at over 50 percent extra on top of base costs, it feels like ordering champagne for a beer budget.
Now, peel back the fiscal onion for the human sting. That £101 million government outlay? It is not Monopoly money. Picture it funding 500 new ICU beds, or vaccinating millions in developing nations, or even patching potholes from Land's End to John o Groats. Taxpayers, already squeezed by inflation and energy hikes, foot this while essential services creak. Investors watch warily as public debt swells, nudging bond yields and mortgage rates. Consumers feel it in stealth taxes or cut services elsewhere. And workers? Frontline heroes from the pandemic era see irony in bureaucracy ballooning while NHS waitlists stretch to infinity. The bereaved families pushing for justice nod to vital work, but plead for efficiency. Even think tanks like TaxPayers Alliance cry foul, dubbing it a disgrace amid spiraling totals.
Here is where irony waltzes in with a grin. The government vows lessons learned for next time, yet the process breeds more friction than fixes. Compare to global peers. Australia's Royal Commission into Covid wrapped key phases quicker, costs contained under equivalent of £50 million total. New Zealand's review? Snappy, insightful, budget friendly. They leaned collaborative, not combative. Sweden skipped a full inquiry, opting data dives and reports that shaped policy sans legal Armageddon. What gives the UK edge in expense? Perhaps a cultural flair for drama, or layers of civil service red tape thicker than London fog. Or maybe it is the adversarial legal system, where every disclosure sparks a fee frenzy.
Dig deeper into economics, and the opportunity cost bites harder. That £300 million plus could multiplier into billions. Invest in AI driven early warning systems, like those trialed in Singapore, spotting outbreaks via wastewater scans before they explode. Or bolster supply chains, learning from ventilator hunts that saw firms pivot from cars to life savers overnight. Historical parallels abound. Post 1918 flu, nations built sanatoriums and surveillance nets, blunting future waves. Today, with climate juicing pathogens, efficiency matters double. Squander here, and next crisis hits harder, costing trillions as in 2020's global GDP nosedive of 3.5 percent.
Another lens reveals reform glimmers. Groups champion a Hillsborough style law, mandating public bodies aid inquiries without foot dragging. It inches through parliament, promising smoother sails. Imagine mandates for timely docs, capped legal budgets, tech led evidence sifting. The inquiry chair herself flags its unprecedented breadth, moving faster than predecessors despite scale. Progress, albeit pricey. Families of the lost argue savings in lives and economy dwarf tabs, if lessons stick. Fair point. A well run sequel averts sequels altogether.
Yet, humor lurks in the absurd. Envision the 248 staffers as pandemic paperwork ninjas, battling FOI requests like zombies in a B movie. External lawyers, billing by the minute, rival rockstar tour managers. And modules? Ten acts in a never ending play, with audiences yawning by intermission. Pop culture nods to The Thick of It, where spin doctors turn crises into comedies. Real life outdoes fiction when WhatsApp wars headline news.
Globetrotting perspective adds spice. I have dodged tear gas in Hong Kong protests, sipped tea in Tehran bazaars, filed from Brussels Brexit bunkers. Nowhere does bureaucratic ballet match Britain's blend of pomp and procrastination. Other nations grill leaders via committees or commissions, sans such fiscal fireworks. France's Senate probe into Covid? Lean, laser focused. Even India's messy parliamentary panels move sans million lawyer mobs. UK's model, noble in intent, needs streamlining lest it bankrupt the pursuit of truth.
Twist incoming. This cash cow might birth a phoenix. Final reports could blueprint resilience, from modular hospitals to citizen apps tracking symptoms. Economic insights? Procurement modules expose tender tricks, saving billions next round. Preparedness findings? Echo 2016 exercises warning of exactly this scenario, ignored till too late. If action follows, £300 million becomes bargain basement for security.
Bottom line, dear reader, as we clink virtual glasses. Inquiries are democracy's mirror, reflecting flaws and fixes. This one's mirror is gold plated, but polish it right, and future stares back stronger. Laugh at the ledger now, lest next pandemic pens a sadder sequel. After all, in politics as in comedy, timing is everything, and efficiency the punchline we all need.
By Margaret Sullivan